Medical Assessor Code of Conduct
This Code sets out principles of conduct and professional behaviour to guide Medical Assessors in the performance of their statutory functions and to promote discussion and awareness of issues of conduct.
- Annual Review
Appeal Case Summaries
Appeal Case Summaries
- Appeal Case Summaries 032021
- Appeal Case Summaries 042021
- Appeal Case Summaries 052021
- Appeal Case Summaries 062021
- Appeal Case Summaries - 072021
- Appeal Case Summaries 082021
- Appeal Case Summaries - 092021
- Appeal Case Summaries 102021
- Appeal Case Summaries 112021
- Appeal Case Summaries 122021
- Appeal Case Summaries 012022
- Appeal Case Summaries - 032022
- Appeal Case Summaries - 042022
- Appeal Case Summaries - 052022
- Appeal Case Summaries - 022022
- Appeal Case Summaries - 062022
- Appeal Case Summaries
- Instrument of Delegation Judge Gerard Phillips 1 March 2021
- Instrument of Delegation Rodney Parson Tables A and B
- Instrument of Delegation Marie Johns
- Instrument of Delegation Marianne Christmann
- Instrument of Delegation Judge Gerard Phillips 15 April 2021
- Instrument of Sub-Delegation dated 30 April 2021.pdf
- Instrument of delegation dated 23 May 2021.pdf
- Instrument of Delegation dated 25 August 2021
- President Instrument of delegation to G Capel dated 21 January 2022
- Division Head Instrument of delegation to G Capel dated 20 January 2022
- President Instrument of delegation to J Bamber dated 24 January 2022.pdf
- Division Head Instrument of delegation to J Bamber dated 24 January 2022.pdf
- Instrument of Delegation - Division Head Workers Compensation Division 25.01.22.pdf
- Instrument of Sub-Delegation - Division Head Workers Compensation Division 25.01.22.pdf
- Instrument of Revocation - Principal Registrar 25.01.2022.pdf
- Instrument of Sub-Delegation - Principal Registrar 25.01.2022.pdf
- Instrument of Sub-Delegation - Director Legal and Policy 25.01.22.pdf
- Table-A-PIC-delegations-PIC-Act-and-regulations-updated-17 February 2022.pdf
- Table-B-PIC-delegations-Rules-Updated-17 February 2022.pdf
- INSTRUMENT OF DELEGATION- 3 March 2022.pdf
- Table-B-PIC-delegations-Rules-Updated-3 March 2022.pdf
- Key Performance Indicators
2022 Legal Bulletins
- Legal Bulletin No. 88 - 25112022
- Legal Bulletin No. 87 - 18112022
- Legal Bulletin No. 86 - 11112022
- Legal Bulletin No. 85 - 04112022
- Legal Bulletin No. 84
- Legal Bulletin No. 83 - 21102022
- Legal Bulletin No. 82 - 14102022
- Legal Bulletin No. 81 - 07102022
- Legal Bulletin No. 80 - 30092022
- Legal Bulletin No. 79
- Legal Bulletin No. 78
- Legal Bulletin No. 77
- Legal Bulletin No. 76
- Legal Bulletin No. 75
- Legal Bulletin No. 74
- Legal Bulletin No. 72
- Legal Bulletin No. 71
- Legal Bulletin No. 70
- Legal Bulletin No. 69
- Legal Bulletin No. 68
- Legal Bulletin No. 67
- Legal Bulletin No. 66
- Legal Bulletin No. 65
- Legal Bulletin No. 64
- Legal Bulletin No. 63
- Legal Bulletin No. 62
- Legal Bulletin No. 61
- Legal Bulletin No. 60
- Legal Bulletin No. 59
- Legal Bulletin No. 58
- Legal Bulletin No. 57
- Legal Bulletin No. 56
- Legal Bulletin No. 55
- Legal Bulletin No. 54
- Legal Bulletin No. 53
- Legal Bulletin No. 52
- Legal Bulletin No. 51
- Legal Bulletin No. 50
- Legal Bulletin No. 49
- Legal Bulletin No. 48
- Legal Bulletin No. 47
- Legal Bulletin No. 46
- Legal Bulletin No. 44
- Legal Bulletin No. 43
2021 Legal Bulletins
- Legal Bulletin No. 42
- Legal Bulletin No. 41
- Legal Bulletin No. 40 - 03122021
- Legal Bulletin No. 39 - 26112021
- Legal Bulletin No. 38
- Legal Bulletin No. 37 - 12112021
- Legal Bulletin No. 36 05112021
- Legal Bulletin No. 35 29102021
- Legal Bulletin No. 34 - 22102021
- Legal Bulletin No. 33 - 15102021
- Legal Bulletin No. 32 - 08.10.2021
- Legal Bulletin No. 31
- Legal Bulletin No. 30 - 24092021
- Legal Bulletin No. 29 - 17092021
- Legal Bulletin No. 28 - 10092021
- Legal Bulletin No. 27 - 03092021
- Legal Bulletin No. 26 - 270821
- Legal Bulletin No. 25 - 200821
- Legal Bulletin No. 24 - 13082021
- Legal Bulletin No. 23 - 06082021
- Legal Bulletin No. 22 - 300721
- Legal Bulletin No. 21 - 23072021
- Legal Bulletin No. 20 - 16072021
- Legal Bulletin No. 19 - 09072021
- Legal Bulletin No. 18 - 02072021
- Legal Bulletin No. 17 - 25062021
- Legal Bulletin No. 16 - 18062021
- Legal Bulletin No. 15 - 11062021
- Legal Bulletin No. 14 - 04062021
- Legal Bulletin No. 13 - 28052021
- Legal Bulletin No. 12 - 21052021
- Legal Bulletin No. 11 - 14052021
- Legal Bulletin No. 10 - 07052021
- Legal Bulletin No. 9 - 30042021
- Legal Bulletin No. 8 - 23042021
- Legal Bulletin No. 7 - 16042021
- Legal Bulletin No. 6 - 09042021
- Legal Bulletin No. 5 - 01042021
- Legal Bulletin No. 4 - 26032021
- Legal Bulletin No. 3 - 19032021
- Legal Bulletin No. 2 - 12032021
- Legal Bulletin No. 1 - 05032021
- 2022 Legal Bulletins
Papers and Presentations
- PIC Seminar Workers Compensation February 2021
- PIC Legal Seminar Motor Accidents 080221
- PIC Insurer Seminar Motor Accidents 080221
- Speeches by the President
- Inaugural ceremonial sitting speeches
Personal Injury Commission News
- 2022 Personal Injury Commission News
2021 Personal Injury Commission News
- Medical Disputes Suitable for Paper Assessment September 2021
- Edition No.20
- Edition No.19
- Edition No.18
- Edition No.17 27102021
- Edition No.16 - 19102021
- Edition No.15
- Edition No.14
- Edition No.13
- Edition No.12
- Edition No.11
- Edition No.10 - 22072021
- Edition No.9
- Edition No.8
- Edition No.7
- Edition No.6
- Edition No.5
- Edition No.4
- Edition No.3
- Edition No. 2
- Edition No. 1
- Procedural Direction PIC1 – Conduct of parties during proceedings
- Procedural Direction PIC2 – Determination of matters ‘on the papers'
- Procedural Direction PIC3 – Documents and late documents
- Procedural Direction PIC4 – Expert Witness Evidence
- Procedural Direction PIC5 – Schedule of Earnings
- Procedural Direction PIC6 – Medical Assessments
- Procedural Direction PIC7 – Appeals, reviews, reconsiderations and correction of obvious errors in medical disputes
- Procedural Direction PIC9 – Production of Information and Calling of Witnesses
- Procedural Direction PIC10 - Personal Injury Commission Hearings
- Procedural Direction PIC11 – Medical Assessments Procedure – COVID-19
- Procedural Direction WC1 – Compensation payable on death
- Procedural Direction WC2 – Interim payment directions
- Procedural Direction WC3 – Presidential appeals and questions of law
- Procedural Direction WC4 – Work injury damages
- Procedural Direction WC5 – Work Capacity Disputes
- Procedural Direction WC6 – Workplace injury management disputes
- Procedural Direction WC7 – Reconsiderations of decisions of the Commission
- Procedural Direction MA1 – Stood over proceedings
- Procedural Direction MA2 – Merit review
- Procedural Direction MA3 – Approval of damages settlement
- Procedural Direction MA4 – Appointed representatives
- Procedural Direction MA5 – Matters unsuitable for assessment and mandatory exemptions
- Procedural Direction MA6 – Review of a single merit review by a review panel
- Procedural Direction MA7 – Claims disputes
- Motor Accidents Division
- Workers Compensation Division
Personal Injury Commission Medical Assessor Code of Conduct
- This Code of Conduct is issued by the President of the Personal Injury Commission of New South Wales under section 16 of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020.
- Medical Assessors are engaged in work of significant public service. They are responsible for the independent assessment of medical disputes involving citizens who have been injured at work or on the road, their employers and insurers.
- This Code sets out principles of conduct and professional behaviour to guide Medical Assessors in the performance of their statutory functions and to promote discussion and awareness of issues of conduct.
- This Code also informs Commission users about the values, principles and standards of professional conduct expected of Medical Assessors.
- Compliance with this Code will enhance public confidence in the Commission and its processes and is an important aspect of the Commission meeting the objects of the PIC Act. It is also designed to promote collegiate, professional and harmonious relations among Medical Assessors.
- This Code may be varied from time to time to ensure its relevance.
- The following definitions apply to this Code:
- AMA 4 and AMA 5 – mean the American Medical Association’s Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 4th edition and 5th edition respectively.
- Commission – refers to the Personal Injury Commission of New South Wales.
- Commission Rules and Procedural Directions – refers to the practice and procedure to be followed in proceedings before the Commission.
- Confidential information – materials and information, both printed and electronic, that are provided to Medical Assessors in the course of their duties for the Commission are confidential unless they are otherwise available in the public domain, such as on the Commission’s website. The Medical Assessor’s Practice Manual is a confidential document.
- Enabling legislation – refers to the workers compensation legislation and the motor accidents legislation as defined in section 5 of the PIC Act.
- Member – refers to all members of the Commission including Presidential, non-Presidential and sessional Members.
- Medical Assessor – refers to all persons appointed as Medical Assessors for the purposes and functions specified in the enabling legislation.
- PIC Act – means the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020.
- Social media – websites and applications that enable users to create and share content or to participate in social networking
Responsibility of the President and Principal Registrar
- It is the responsibility of the President and Principal Registrar to assist Medical Assessors to comply with this Code and to perform their responsibilities as Medical Assessors, through the provision of appropriate training, leadership, advice and support.
Upholding the Objects of the PIC Act
- The objects of the PIC Act are set out under section 3 and include:
- ensuring the Commission:
- is independent (s 3(a));
- is accessible, professional and responsive to the needs of its users;
- is open and transparent about its processes;
- encourages early dispute resolution (s 3(b)).
- enabling the Commission to resolve the real issues in proceedings, justly, quickly, cost effectively and with as little formality as possible (s 3(c)).
- ensuring that the decisions of the Commission are timely, fair, consistent and of a high quality (s 3(d)).
- promoting public confidence in the decision-making of the Commission and in the conduct of its Members
(s 3 (e)).
- ensuring the Commission:
- Medical Assessors are expected to perform their duties and conduct themselves consistently with these objects.
- Medical Assessors have the following general responsibilities, both in their functions as a Medical Assessor and in their personal activities:
- to uphold the law, including being aware of and complying with legislation dealing with privacy, discrimination and corruption;
- to uphold high standards of ethics, integrity and honesty;
- to maintain high professional standards of conduct.
12. In performing their duties, Medical Assessors should at all times strive to give effect to the following values (derived from A Guide to Standards of Conduct for Tribunal Members issued by the Administrative Review Council).
Respect for the Law
13. Medical Assessors should demonstrate respect for the law in the performance of their functions, including demonstrating an awareness and understanding of statutory obligations, rules, procedural directions and procedural requirements imposed by the Commission.
14. Medical Assessors should also demonstrate respect for the law in their private lives.
15. In exercising their functions, Medical Assessors must:
a. abide by the principles of procedural fairness, including:
- ensuring the injured person is given an opportunity to provide a history in relation to the injury and any subsequent condition;
- ensuring that the injured person is presented with any inconsistencies noted in supporting material or observed in the course of an examination, and is provided with an opportunity to explain those inconsistencies before drawing any conclusions;
- considering the submissions of all parties to the dispute; and
- ensuring the parties are given an opportunity to address any articles or research material that a Medical Assessor proposes to rely on.
b. be aware of and address appropriately, any barriers which are likely to impede parties in presenting their case. Such barriers may include, but are not limited to, language, cultural background, lack of literacy, disability and self-representation;
c. ensure medical assessments are based on examination, clinical judgement and review of investigations, reports and other relevant information;
d. ensure all material contained in the referral is reviewed;
e. ensure reasonable time is allowed to examine the injured person;
f. not provide any opinion to the injured person about their claim, condition or treatment;
g. be professional when commenting on the opinion of other clinicians.
Conflicts of Interest
16. Medical Assessors must conduct medical assessments in an impartial manner and withdraw from the assessment process where they are unable to do so.
17. Medical Assessors must advise the Principal Registrar, as soon as practicable, of any potential conflict of interest that may prevent them from performing their duties. This includes any factor that may give rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias. The Principal Registrar will advise how the matter should proceed.
18. Medical Assessors may seek advice and guidance from the Principal Registrar in relation to any potential conflict of interest or other issue in relation to undertaking functions as a Medical Assessor.
19. The Principal Registrar may keep a register of conflict of interest declarations.
20. Medical Assessors should:
a. not accept a referral to provide a medical assessment of any person whom they have previously treated, assessed for the purpose of preparing a medico-legal report or been acquainted;
b. not accept a referral to provide a medical assessment as an independent medical expert, where they previously assessed the injured person in their capacity as a Medical Assessor;
c. not provide comment to the media on specific cases that are before the Commission for assessment or determination, or have been dealt with by the Commission;
d. if providing comment to the media on a matter unrelated to their Commission functions and responsibilities, they should not identify themselves as a Medical Assessor;
e. refrain from participating in any commentary, criticism or advocacy for change in relation to the PIC Act or its enabling legislation, unless as part of a review at the request of the President or other government agency;
f. declare any close personal relationships or pecuniary interests that may give rise to a possible conflict of interest. Such declarations are to be made to the Principal Registrar and are to be treated with confidence;
21. Medical Assessors may provide a medical assessment as an independent medical expert, where the injured person has been assessed by a Medical Assessor, provided such assessment and report does not critique the medical assessment or medical assessment certificate of the Medical Assessor.
22. Medical Assessors are to perform their duties independently, free from external influence and free from fear of adverse consequences.
23. Medical Assessors should not allow themselves to be put in a position where their independence may be compromised or perceived to be compromised.
24. Medical Assessors must maintain their independence in the discharge of their duties. Notwithstanding any matter within this Code, Medical Assessors must satisfy themselves that no conflict exists in the discharge of their duties to the Commission.
Diligence and Timeliness
25. Medical Assessors are to be diligent and timely in the performance of their duties. They should take all reasonable steps to maintain and enhance the knowledge, skills and personal qualities necessary for the performance of their duties.
26. In particular, Medical Assessors are to:
a. conduct medical assessments accurately;
b. provide medical assessments and make decisions in a timely and appropriate manner with a view to ensuring that the process is efficient, effective and inexpensive;
c. undertake and participate in professional development and Commission training programs to enhance relevant knowledge and skills;
d. keep informed of developments in substantive and procedural matters within the jurisdiction of the Commission relevant to their duties;
e. ensure medical assessments are consistent with legal authority, relevant Commission Rules and Procedural Directions and guidance material, or provide detailed reasons where they are not followed;
f. support and encourage, where possible, the professional development of colleagues;
g. ensure they are proficient in the use of technology including the Commission’s electronic case management system, digital provision of documents, the Commission’s intranet and extranet, conducting assessments by audio-visual link where appropriate, and other technological developments implemented by the Commission.
27. Medical Assessors should act with honesty, fairness, respect and commitment.
28. Medical Assessors should:
a. not knowingly take advantage of or benefit from information, not publicly available, obtained in the course of performing their functions;
b. not use their position as a Medical Assessor improperly to gain or seek to gain any advantage or benefit for themselves or any other person;
c. be scrupulous in the use of Commission resources;
d. refrain from conduct which would bring the Commission and/or Medical Assessors into disrepute.
Accountability and Transparency
29. Medical Assessors are accountable for their assessments, decisions and actions taken as Medical Assessors and have a responsibility to be open and frank about their assessments, decisions, actions and inaction in relation to their functions.
30. In particular, Medical Assessors are to:
a. participate in performance evaluations conducted by the Commission;
b. co-operate fully in complaint investigations carried out by the Commission in accordance with the Access and Equity Service Charter;
c. regularly review and evaluate their own performance and capacity.
Respect for Persons
31. Medical Assessors are to conduct all interactions in the course of their functions in the Commission in a manner that is patient, courteous and respectful of all parties, interpreters, representatives, Commission staff and others with whom Medical Assessors have to deal.
32. Medical Assessors should endeavour to understand and be sensitive to the needs of persons involved in proceedings before the Commission, including:
a. demonstrating patience, courtesy and respect in their own conduct and demeanour;
b. communicating in a clear, plain manner so as to be understood by the parties;
c. being aware of and responsive to cultural and other sensitivities in relation to forms of address, conduct and dress.
33. The Commission recognises the importance of fairness, dignity and respect for others in the workplace. Each person in the workplace, including Commission staff, medical staff and Medical Assessors, should have a safe and secure place in which to work. The Commission does not tolerate inappropriate workplace behaviour, which includes bullying, harassment, sexual harassment, other forms of unlawful discrimination, vilification and violence.
34. Medical Assessors must be familiar and comply with all relevant policies in relation to workplace behaviour.
Privacy and Confidentiality
35. Medical Assessors and those subject to their direction and control must respect the confidentiality of the medical disputes that are provided for assessment and determination and not disclose any confidential information otherwise than as permitted by law.
36. Otherwise than in the exercise of Commission functions, Medical Assessors must comply with:
a. Information Protection Principles in Part 2, Division 1 of the Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998;
b. Health Privacy Principles in Schedule 1 of the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002.
Gifts, Benefits and Hospitality
37. Where gifts or benefits are offered, or social invitations extended, by parties or representatives in Commission proceedings, to Medical Assessors, these should be declined.
38. Medical Assessors may seek advice from the Principal Registrar in relation to social invitations received and whether they should be declined.
39. In circumstances where gifts cannot be or it is inappropriate for a gift to be declined, the Principal Registrar should be informed so that it may be recorded in the Commission’s gift register. The gift may be retained, donated to a charity, used for the benefit of Medical Assessors or staff generally or publicly display in the Commission’s premises may be appropriate, depending on the circumstances.
40. Medical assessors are to seek the President’s approval to deliver presentations or publish papers or studies about the PIC practice and procedure, PIC Act or enabling legislation. If case studies from the medical assessors’ work within the PIC are referred to, these must be de-identified in such a way to ensure that the identity of any individual could not be apparent from the consideration of the paper or the presentation.
Committee Membership and Other Groups
41. Medical Assessors should inform the Principal Registrar of any positions held on any committee, board or other group and must withdraw from any discussions about the operation of the PIC Act or its enabling legislation.
42. The Principal Registrar may keep a register of positions held by Medical Assessors.
43. Medical Assessors must ensure that they do not engage in any of the following activities on social media:
a. create content that is relevant to the business of the Commission;
b. discuss or share posts on topics that directly or indirectly reflect on the practices and operations of the Commission;
c. engage with any content that falls within the above definitions in non-written ways including but not limited to “liking” or “reposting” such content.
44. If a Medical Assessor becomes aware of an instance of behaviour that could be corrupt conduct, maladministration, or criminal conduct, relating to the Commission, the Medical Assessor should report it promptly to the President or Principal Registrar, and/or, if appropriate, to the Independent Commission Against Corruption. (Refer to section 8 of the Independent Commission Against Corruption Act 1988 for guidance regarding the general nature of corrupt conduct.)
Post Service Conduct
45. After ceasing to be a Medical Assessor of the Commission, it is expected that a former Medical Assessor:
a. would continue to behave in a way that upholds the integrity and good reputation of the Commission;
b. would not use or take advantage of confidential information obtained in the course of his or her duties as a Medical Assessor.
Complaints and Concerns
46. Complaints to the Commission in relation to Medical Assessors will be dealt with as outlined in Commission’s Access and Equity Service Charter.
47. Medical Assessors may raise, with the Principal Registrar and/or the Medical Assessor Reference Group, any concerns regarding other Medical Assessors, Commission Members and staff, and Commission practice and procedure.
Protection of Medical Assessor
48. Any thing done or omitted to be done by a Medical Assessor in exercising the functions conferred or imposed by or under the PIC Act or its enabling legislation does not, if the thing was done or omitted to be done in good faith, subject the Medical Assessor personally to any action, liability, claim or demand.
49. A Medical Assessor is, in any legal proceedings, competent but not compellable to give evidence or produce documents in respect of any matter in which the Medical Assessor was involved in the course of exercising the functions conferred or imposed by or under the PIC Act or its enabling legislation.
50. Medical Assessors may seek advice, guidance and legal assistance from the Principal Registrar in relation to any external complaint, action, request or demand made on or against them in relation to undertaking their functions as a Medical Assessor.
Compliance with this Code
52. This Code does not stand alone but forms part of the accountability framework within which both the Commission and the Medical Assessors operate. It is complementary to the Commission’s procedures and policies, including the Terms of Appointment, Medical Assessor professional development framework and the Commission’s complaints process.
His Hon Judge Gerard Phillips
1 March 2021